Ryan Adams-1989

taylor_swift_ryan_adams-600x600

Taylor Swift’s 1989 was the execution of a coup. The album’s sharp turn, coupled with Swift’s social media constancy and well-crafted public relations ploys, lifted her into her throne as current queen of the pop world.

1989 pushed aside timid romanticism for a fresh, grown up confidence, her latest tracks featuring sleek, glossy production and arena-ready hooks.

So what an intriguing jolt it was when prolific yet low-key alternative rocker Ryan Adams announced he would be covering Swift’s U.S.’s best-selling album of 2014 in its entirety. While it’s definitely not the first or even the tenth time Adams has decided to try his hand at someone else’s songs, “1989” had to be one of his more interesting choices.

The outcome, as it turns out, is rather hit-or-miss. Adam’s story-telling singing voice sometimes channels a weak Lou Reed drawl, sometimes a Bruce Springsteen-esque snarl, dubious qualities when contrasted against “1989”’s originally glamorous 80s sound.

Some of the more heartfelt songs do benefit from the tender, barely-there vocals, allowing them the melancholy fragility that was often lost in the pop veneer. “Blank Space”, its polished crispness replaced by a fuzzy mumbling,  becomes addictively sad. Some of Adams’ renditions may leave listeners curious as to how “Welcome to New York” or “Wildest Dreams” would have sounded had Swift stuck to her tear-droppy acoustic guitar.

Adams goes in an opposite-and successful-direction when he turns up the volume with “Style”, bringing out the funky riff hiding in its background with some snarling guitar.

But as expected, some songs, like the hyper comeback anthem “Shake It Off”, become miserably dull and awkward under his direction. There’s some songs which were not meant to be slowed down and mumbled; Adams’ voice stumbles along like an old man that can’t keep up. Similarly, the focused fury of “Bad Blood” gets watered down into submission.

It’s always nice to see artists being enthusiastic about their fellow musician’s output, and it’s certainly something that shouldn’t be discouraged; it gives new perspectives to songs we hear on the radio fifty thousand times and, if anything, it’s a fun experiment.

It may be too much to ask that every song be as good or better than the original; if even a couple of them gain new life, it should be considered a success.

Taken from that perspective, Adams can count himself a lucky winner.

Advertisements

2 Replies to “Ryan Adams-1989”

  1. What was the song with the hipster reference? I think it was “Style” where he namedropped a band and it felt like he was just trying to come off as cool and in-the-know.

    1989 was an event but not a great album even if “Blank Space” was brilliant. After you spin it a while and the hullabaloo that surrounds it is forgotten, it’s a decent Pop album. Adams felt like he was trying to come off as cool here. Sadly, he ruined “Blank Space” by forgetting the song is supposed to be light.

    Like

    1. It was Daydream Nation, a Sonic Youth album. (:

      It’s true that the hype over 1989 may have been bigger than the actual album, but I still respect and enjoy a lot of the songs on it, I feel it’s important the way Taylor Swift has grown as a songwriter, not to mention the big shift in sound.

      “Blank Space” was a fun song when Swift kept it light, but I was okay with Adams reworking it as a slower sad song. That’s the cool thing about covers, sometimes the songs work in more than one way.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s